Nonduality




 
Buddhist Numbered Lists



Compiled and Edited by Greg Goode, Ph.D.

Greg is editor of the Nondualism and Western Philosophers page, author of Presence, and compiled and edited Nondualism, Yogas, and Personality Characteristics


In Buddhism, the creation of numbered lists such as The Four Noble Truths and the Eightfold Path have been time-honored ways of presenting information. During much of Buddhism's 2,500-year history, the teachings have been conveyed and recited orally. Numbered lists in the sutras and commentaries serve to make the teachings more easily remembered. Even in the modern world of print and electronic media, presenting the multi-faceted Buddhist teachings in list form makes them easier to remember and ponder. It also has the psychological advantage of making the teachings stand out against the background of non-numbered information.

The present list is a beginning compilation of Buddhist numbered lists on prominent subjects in Buddhist teaching. This compilation has been for my own study. In many texts I have often encountered the mention of a seemingly important numbered list (such as “The Five Corruptions” or “The Six Dusts”) with no explanation. There are over one hundred lists in the present compilation, culled from a wide variety of sutras, commentaries, treatises and reference books. Nevertheless, this is only a beginning and vastly incomplete effort. There has been no effort at providing alternative translations of the English coming from Pali, Sanskrit, Chinese, Japanese, or Tibetan sources (passion vs. desire, or corruptions vs. defilements, etc.) The lists are stronger in the areas of Mahayana, Pure Land, and Zen/Ch'an, and weaker in the areas of Theravada, Abhidharma (psychology and philosophy), Tantra and Dzogchen. Any assistance, additions or corrections are gratefully welcomed!

 
Buddhist Numbered Lists

Numbered Item

Description

   
(01) One Vehicle Great Vehicle Dharma – Mahayana, vehicle of the Bodhisattva.
(02) Two Branches of Mahayana (1) Paramitayana, practice of the 6 paramitas or perfections, (2) Vajrayana/Mantrayana/Tantrayana, the way of the diamond, following the thread of knowledge. Involves mantra, symbolic, esoteric and magical practices.
(02) Two Good Things, Merit and Virtue From Pure Land Buddhism, and the Sutra Translation Committee and the Van Hien Study Group. The same action can lead to merits or virtues, according to the intention. The motive of mundane rewards leads to merits, and the motive of transcendence leads to virtues.

(1) Merits are the blessings (wealth, intelligence, etc.) of the human and celestial realms. They are temporary and subject to birth and death.

(2) Virtues transcend birth and death, and lead to Buddhahood. Pure Land Buddhism mentions four virtues: (i) eternity, (ii) happiness, (iii) True Self, (iv) Purity.

(02) Two Major Afflictions These have a greater and more causal effect than minor afflictions:
(1) Shamelessnes, (2) Impudence.
Back to index
(02) Two Truths Two kinds of truths, each has many instances. (1) Conventional truth of the mundane world, "manifests stillness but is always illuminating" (Hsu Heng Chi/P.H. Wei, quoted in Horizontal Escape) and is immanent in everything. (2) The Ultimate truth transcends dichotomies and is inexplicable. There is the conventional truth of the table (the conventional designation of the table) and the ultimate truth of the table (emptiness of the inherent existence of the table).
(02) Two Kinds of Patience From the Upasakashila Sutra, quoted in Hsing Yun's Being Good. (1) Patience of this world, includes the endurance of hunger, thirst, heat, cold, suffering, and joy. (2) Patience which transcends this world, which includes learning to be steady in belief, wisdom, generosity, compassion, and open-mindedness; learning to be steadfast in our loyalty to the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; and learning to endure insults, beatings, taunting, evil plots against us, greed, anger, ignorance and all the other vile and humiliating things of this world. We learn to endure the unendurable and to accomplish the impossible." (pp. 91-92). Back to index
(02) Two Zen Qualities (1) Kyogai – (Visaya=world/place in Sanskrit) Unified mind/body/behavior, the opposite of dry intellectualization; it is the absence of self-reflectiveness, self-consciousness; it is totally poured into behavior. Like being "narikitta" or totally one with the thing. Can be learned. From G. Victor Sogen Hori, "Koan and Kensho in the Rinzai Zen Curriculum. (2) Majime – wisdom and courage to eliminate the distinctions between actions and thoughts. Both kyogai and majime can be learned, trained. They bespeak genuineness, authenticity. Back to index
(03) Three Baskets (tripitaka) (1) Regulations of the lives of monastics (Vinaya-pitaka), (2) discourses coming from the mouth of the Buddha or his immediate disciples and arranged into 5 collections (Digha-nikaya, Majjhima-nikaya, Samyutta-nikaya, Anguttara-nikaya, Khuddaka-nikaya), (3) Buddhist psychology and philosophy (Abhidharma-pitaka). Back to index
(03) Three Dharma Ages (1) Dharma Perfect Age, Buddha Shakyamuni's demise to 500 years, when enlightenment was often attained, (2) Dharma Semblance Age was the next 1,000 years, when enlightenment was seldom attained, (3) Dharma Ending Age, the next 10,000 years, when enlightenment will rarely be attained. Back to index
(03) Three Dharma Seals Three insights, often used as criteria to determine the genuine-ness of Buddhist teachings – (1) All composite things (samskaras) are impermanent, (2) All dharmas do not have an independent self, (3) Nirvana is perfect peace. Sometimes a fourth is used (4) emptiness. Can be used to determine whether a sutra is authentic, such as the Platform Sutra, about Hui Neng, not Buddha! If it conforms to the Dharma seals, then it's authentic. Back to index
(03) Three Insights Trividya (Sanskrit) (1) All phenomena are impermanent, (2) All phenomena are sorrowful, (3) All phenomena are devoid of essence. Back to index
(03) Three Jewels (triratna) Buddha, Dharma, Sangha. Back to index
(03) Three Ways Phenomena are Interdependent (1) Phenomena are dependent upon other phenomena (red/yellow/green or hot/cold), (2) Phenomena are dependent in part/whole relationships (the chariot and the parts of the chariot), (3) Phenomena are dependent upon a perceiving or cognizing consciousness. Back to index
(03) Three Liberations Also known as the Three gates of nirvana (vimoksha). Meditation that prepares the way for nirvana through the realization of emptiness (shunyata), formlessness (animitta), and passionlessness. The three liberations are (1) the recognition of ego and all dharmas as empty, (2) the recognition of all dharmas as formless and devoid of distinctions, (3) the recognition of existence as unworthy of desire. Back to index
(03) Three Poisons Fundamental evils in life which give rise to human suffering. (1) Greed, (2) Anger, (3) Delusion. In the Dhammapada Sutra it is taught that attachment is the root cause of suffering: "From craving [attachment] springs grief, from craving springs fear; For him who is wholly free from craving, there is no grief, much less fear." Back to index
(03) Three Root Precepts All Bodhisattva precepts or vows derive from these root precepts. (1) Do not do what is evil, (2) Do what is good, (3) Be of benefit to all sentient beings. Back to index
(03) Three Teachings Also known as the Three Learnings – (1) Morality, (2) Meditation, (3) Wisdom. Back to index
(03) Three truths (T'ien-t'ai school) (1) Dharmas possess no independent reality and thus are empty, (2) A dharma has the temporally limited apparent existence of phenomena and can be detected by the senses, (3) the "middle," suchness, the true state is not to be found anywhere other than in phenomena; phenomena and the absolute are one. This truth stands above the other two and includes them. Back to index
(03) Three Turnings of the Wheel of Dharma (1) Theravada, (2) Mahayana, (3) Vajrayana/Mantrayana/Tantrayana. Back to index
(03) Three Vehicles Middle level, "Sravaka Vehicle" or "Theravada" – Sravaka, Pratyekabuddha, and Bodhisattva (Sravakas follow Theravada and eventually become arhats as a result of listening to the Buddhas and following their teachings. Pratyekabuddhas become fully enlightened by meditating on the principle of causality). Back to index
(03) Three woeful paths (apaya) Hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals Back to index
(03) Three worlds (triloka) (1) Kamaloka, desire world, includes humans, hell beings, animals, asuras, and the six classes of gods (2) Rupaloka, desireless corporality or form, includes gods in the dhyana heaven. Rebirth here possible through the four absorptions (3) Arupaloka, formlessness, surely spiritual continuum, consists of the four heavens in which one is born via the practice of the four stages of formlessness. Back to index
(03) Threefold refuge (trisharana) Taking refuge in (1) the Buddha, (2) the Dharma, and (3) the Sangha. Back to index
(03) Triple Realm Also Three Realms, Three Worlds. (1) Realm of Desire (our world), (2) Realm of form (for lesser deities), (3) Realm of formlessness (for higher deities). The Western Pure Land is outside the Triple Realm, beyond retrogression and samsara. Back to index
(04) Four Bases of Spiritual Power From the Anapanasati Sutra
(1) Joy, from composure of mind and determined striving. (2) Energy, the energy that it takes to recognize that the mind is tense. Comes from concentration and determined striving. (3) Purity of mind from concentration/tranquillity and determined striving. (4) The ability to investigate, from concentration/composure and determined striving.
Back to index
(04) Four Benefits of Patience From Master Hsing-Yun's Being Good – (1) Patience dissipates the anger of the one practicing patience, and others as well, (2) Patience is a reliable refuge, (3) Patience is the source of great goodness and is a hidden virtue, (4) Patience is the source or cause of bodhi wisdom. Back to index
(04) Four Bodies (kayas) (1) Dharmakaya, dharma body – the space from which everything arises. Also, the Buddha's true nature, and his unity with everything else. Originally the teaching expounded by the historical Buddha. Also called dharmadhatu. Realized through prajna. Vairochana Buddha (transcendental Buddha) is a symbol.

(2) Sambhogakaya, enjoyment body – points to the experience that there's energy and color and movement. Sound is often a symbol of Sambhogakaya. Also, the result of previous good actions, as the body for a bodhisattva. It exhibits the 32 major marks and the eighty minor marks of a buddha and can be perceived only by a bodhisattva in its last stage of development. Also the ecstasy of enlightenment, the means to convey the experience of emptiness. Amitabha Buddha is a symbol.

(3) Nirmanakaya, body of transformation – the experience that emptiness manifests in form and that form is emptiness, yet we solidify it. Embodied in earthly buddhas and bodhisattvas projected into the world through the meditation of the Sambhogakaya buddhas as a result of their compassion. Nirmanakaya manifestations are to expound the teaching, and are guides on the way to liberation but have no causal force. They are human beings subject to the misery of illness, old age and death, but have the divine eye and divine hearing. Individuality dissolves after death. Shakyamuni Buddha an example.

(4) Svabhavikakaya, "self-nature" body – the fact that the three bodies arise at once. It is the essenceless, emptiness, called svabhaha-shunyata, and related to Madhyamika's teachings on emptiness. Dharmakaya, Sambhogakaya and Nirmanakaya are the three bodies possessed by a Buddha in Mahayana. In Tibetan Buddhism and vajrayana, the body, speech and mind of the master are equated with the three bodies.
Back to index
(04) Four Constituents (1) Earth, (2) Water, (3) Wind, (4) Fire. Back to index
(04) Four Elements (1) the firm, (2) fluid, (3) heating (4), and moving. Back to index
(04) Four Evils (sometimes called "Four Devils") (1) The evil from the five aggregates of form, feeling, perception, tendencies, and consciousness, (2) The evil of death, (3) the evil of suffering. (4), the evil of the Samsaric world. Back to index
(04) Four Great Bodhisattva Virtues (1) Giving, (2) Amiable speech, (3) Conduct beneficial to others, (4) Cooperation. Back to index
(04) Four Foundations (awakenings) of mindfulness (Satipatthana, Hinayana) (1) Mindfulness of body, including breath, bodily elements, and charnel ground contemplation, (2) Mindfulness of feeling, including pleasant/unpleasant, worldly/supramundane and transitory, (3) Mindfulness of mind, incl. Every state of consciousness, (4) Mindfulness of mental objects, including the conditioned-ness and inessentiality of things, presence/absence of the five hindrances, and the fact that all is the five skandas. Back to index
(04) Four Fruits Four stages of spiritual attainment in the Theravadin tradition:
  1. Stream-Winner (shrotapanna, liberation within 7 lifetimes: elimination of (i) the fetter of the belief in the independent existence of the person or taking the aggregates to be the self; overcoming this makes one a noble person, (ii) the fetter of doubt about the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, and about the rules of discipline and interdependent origination, (iii) the fetter of belief in the power of rules and rituals to lead one to liberation (reference to Brahminism)
  2. Once-Returner (sakadagami, liberation in the next lifetime: weakens so as to be un-recognizable to other people but doesn't remove the fetters of (i) sensual desire and (ii) ill will),
  3. Never-Returner (anagami, never reborn in the cycle of birth-and-death, but only in the abodes of the non-returners: has eliminated the fetters of sensual desire and ill will)
  4. Foe-Destroyer (arhat, the stage of the one "no longer in training": the following 5 fetters eliminated, (i) attachment to the sphere of form, (ii) attachment to the formless sphere, (iii) conceit, (iv) agitation, (v) ignorance). Back to index
(04) Four Great Debts Debts to (1) One's parents, (2) the Three Treasures, (3) The founders of the nation and enlightened temporal leaders, (4) All sentient beings, as having been one's parents in past lives. Back to index
(04) Four Aspects of Friendship From the Dirgha Agama – (1) Stop bad behavior, (2) Be kind, (3) Help each other, (4) Share the same lot. Back to index
(04) Four Kinds of Right Striving From the Anapanasati Sutra

(1)   Cultivate zeal for the non-arising of non-arisen unwholesome states of mind. That is, cultivate a mind that has joyful interest and enthusiasm so that is free of unwholesome states. The result is joy and upliftment.

(2)   Cultivate zeal for the abandonment of arisen unwholesome states of mind. That is, turn away from burdensome emotional states such as anger, sadness, jealousy, anxiety, stress, depression, fear, etc., and replace them with a mind of joyful interest and enthusiasm.

(3)   Cultivate zeal for the arising of non-arisen wholesome states of mind. That is, strive to make effort, arouse energy, exert the mind, and strive.

(4)   Cultivate zeal for the continuation and non-disappearance of already-arisen wholesome states of mind. Strive for the continuation, the increase and fulfillment of these states of mind, making effort, exerting the mind and striving. In this way, many of [the Buddha's] students have reached the consummation of perfection of direct knowledge.

Back to index

(04) Four Immeasurables (Brahma-vihara, a meditation where the practitioner arouses these four positive states of mind and radiates them outwards in all directions) – (1) limitless kindness (maitri) towards all beings, (2) limitless compassion (karuna) towards those who are suffering, (3) limitless joy (mudita) over the salvation of others from suffering, (4) limitless equanimity (upeksha) towards friend and foe. Back to index
(04) Four Levels of Teachings From Gyel-tsap's Illumination of the Essential Meanings of (Nagarjuna's) "Precious Garland of Madhyamika," quoted in Jeffrey Hopkins' Precious Garland, pp. 90-91. "[Buddhas] teach the doctrines that they (the students) can bear as objects of their minds. The stages are as follows:

(1)   To some they teach doctrines to turn them away from ill-deeds such as killing; this is so that these trainees who have the thought-patterns of beings of small capacity may achieve the ranks of gods or humans as fruits of their merit.

(2)   To some trainees who have the thought-patterns of beings of middle capacity they teach doctrines based on the duality of apprehended object and apprehending subject and that cyclic existence one-pointedly is to be abandoned and nirvana is one-pointedly to be adopted.

(3)   To some trainees they teach ultimately established consciousness empty of a difference in substantial entity between apprehended object and apprehending subject, thereby teaching to them [doctrine that is] not based on duality.

(4)   To some trainees of highest faculties, who will achieve unsurpassed enlightenment, they teach [doctrine] that has an essence of emptiness – the profound mode of subsistence [of phenomena] frightening to the fearful who adhere to the true existence of things – and compassion." Back to index

(04) Four Noble Truths (1) The Truth of Suffering, (2) The Truth of the origin of suffering through desire, (3) The Truth of the cessation of suffering through the elimination of desire, (4) The Truth of the means of the ending of suffering through the eightfold path. Back to index
(04) Four Perfect Exertions (Samyak-prahanani) The Buddha recommended these to avoid unwholesome factors in the future and eliminate the present ones: (1) the exertion of restraint (avoiding unwholesome factors), (2) the exertion of overcoming (unwholesome factors), (3) the exertion of developing wholesome factors, esp. enlightenment, (4) the exertion of maintaining wholesome factors. These are identical with the sixth of the eight-fold path, Right Effort/exertion. Back to index
(04) Four Propositions (1) Existence, (2) Non-existence, (3) Both, (4) Neither. The 100 errors are derived from these propositions. Back to index
(04) Four Basic Qualities of Nirvana From Master Hsing-Yun's Being Good – (1) Nothing arises in nirvana, (2) Nothing abides in Nirvana, (3) Nirvana is selfless, (4) Nirvana lacks nothing. Back to index
(04) Four Rules to Observe (1) Follow the Dharma, not the teacher, (2) Follow the meaning, not the words, (3) Follow wisdom, not knowledge, (4) Follow the ultimate truth, not apparent truths. Back to index
(04) Four Stages of Absorption (Dhyana, Ch'an, Zen) (1) Relinquishing of desires and unwholesome factors, reached by conceptualization and discursive thought; there is joyful interest and well-being, (2) Coming to rest of conceptualization and discursive thought, attainment of inner calm, one-pointedness of mind; joyful interest and well-being continue, (3) Joy disappears, replaced by equanimity (upeksha); one is alert, aware, feels well-being, (4) Only equanimity and wakefulness are present. Back to index
(04) Four Stages of Cultivation